Latest Reader Case Studies

Reader Case Study: We moved to Atlanta with four children and we could want to move again!

Reader Case Study: We moved to Atlanta with four children and we could want to move again!

Naomi, her husband Jon, and their four children just lately bought their houses within the suburb of Atlanta and moved to a new residence in the Atlanta suburb. The thing is closed, right? Not exactly! Naomi and Jon try to lower their value of dwelling, a smaller residence, the closeness of grandparents and more variety. We assist them get this out within the current Reader case research!

Case research are the economic and life problems that Frugalwoods reader sends me by asking the Frugalwoods individuals to weigh. Then, the Frugalwoods nation (it's you!), Reads them and provides recommendation, encouragement, insights and suggestions in the comments part. For example, check out the last month's case research.

I'll give updates on our case research on the bottom of every case research for several months after the matter has been raised. All you’ve got requested for a neater method to hold monitor of a case research updates and I’ve heard your standards :)! Here’s a record of all case studies that presently have an update that is given at the end of the mail (and a touch that in case you are a earlier case research get together who has not but sent your update, send it to your followers to hear about you!):

  • Reader Case Research: Earn extra, spend less or each? (Julie's Story, revealed in October 2016)
  • Reader Case Research: Stay at residence with your child or return to work? (Kelly's story, revealed in November 2016)
  • Reader Case Research: The Over-gifting In-Legal guidelines Occasion! (Grace's story, revealed in December 2016)
  • Reader Case Research: Renovations and Holidays (Audrey's Story, revealed in January 2017)
  • Reader Case Research: Help me determine how to pay $ 185,000 for scholar loans (Bridget's Story, February 2017) )
  • Reader Case Research: Grad Faculty Dilemma (Story of Emily, revealed in March 2017)
  • Reader Case Research: Can We Buy Your Dream House? (Jack & Elizabeth's story, revealed in April 2017)
  • Reader Case Research: We have Van, now we need a plan! (Florence and Anna's story, revealed in Might 2017)
  • Reader Case Research: Purchase or not to buy in Sydney, Australia? (Jemma & Greg's story, revealed in June 2017)
  • Reader Case Research: Getting Began from Scratch in Canada; Where do I’m going from here? (Alison's story, revealed in July 2017)
  • Reader Case Research: Shifting to Europe from South Africa, Making an attempt to End (Clara Story, revealed in August 2017)
  • Reader Case Research: Should We Keep (San Francisco) Or Should We Go now? (Melanie & Kurt's story, revealed in September 2017)
  • Reader Case Research: Quarterly Disaster in Nashville, TN! (The Story of Steph & Zach, revealed in October 2017)
  • Reader Case Research: Rangers of the Nationwide Park for Finance (The Ranger Story, revealed in November 2017)
  • Reader Case Research: Londoners Marvel About Buying a Property (Betty & David's Story, revealed in December) 2017)
  • Reader Case Research: At age 57, it's not over but! (Lucy's story, revealed in January 2018)
  • Reader Case Research: Brooklyn to LA with Baby (FrugalBrooklyn Story, revealed in February 2018)
  • Reader Survey: Debt and Goals in Queensland, Australia (Sam & Keith Story, revealed in March 2018) [19659005] Reader Case Research: Single Psychologist Saving in NYC (Lauren Story, revealed in April 2018)
  • Reader Survey: How Most cancers Analysis Modifications Every little thing (Emily & John's Story, revealed in Might 2018)
  • ] Reader Case Research: Should We Buy a Campsite and Laundry ? (Payton & Riley's story, revealed in July 2018)

In all probability you don't have to say the following, because you are all the friendliest, most polite commentator on the web, however please notice that Frugalwoods is a court-free area where we attempt to help one another, not to condemn.

And a disclaimer that I am not a educated monetary professional and encourage individuals not to make critical monetary selections based mostly solely on what one individual advises on the Web. I encourage everybody to do their own analysis in order that they will determine their greatest practices for his or her economies.

I'm bringing Naomi, this month's case research, to take it here!

Naomi's story

Pretty boy of Naomi & Joni

Whats up Mrs Frugalwoods and the Frugalwoods nation! I'm Naomi, I'm 37 years previous and my husband Jon (39 years previous) and I’ve four children who’re three, four, 11 and 13 years of age. We reside in the Atlanta suburb of Georgia. The question we are coming to for recommendation is a current change which may not have been the most effective concept.

In March 2018, we bought our house intent to keep away from the large street development that was positioned around our neighbors. We planned to move to a inexpensive area that’s nearer to my very own laws and lives an hour away. Our home was bought shortly, however it was more durable for us to determine to depart our high-quality faculty area than we would assume. It was also a challenge to take a look at houses on the market in one other area with two small children, and two older children at college when navigating the Atlanta area.

We could purchase a costlier residence in our neighboring nation. all the time admired, it's only a mile from the house we just bought. On the constructive aspect, street development was accomplished after years of hassle. I admit that I used to be a busy choice to buy this house in order to avoid switching twice. As well as, this house is situated in the identical faculty district, so our children didn't need to change faculties.

Quick Road

I instantly regretted the decision to upgrade and stay in the current space, as there was solely $ 123Okay left in our former mortgage and it will have been paid off for 11 years. Although $ 150Okay has fallen into a brand new house, this mortgage is more than double. We have $ 257,000 left, and it's a 30-year mortgage with a slightly greater interest rate. The home owner association (HOA) and utility payments are also larger. Within the mild of all this, I am critically considering that we can move once more so that we can virtually meet the objectives of the proximity of smaller housing loans, a more numerous neighborhood and grandparents. However I hate the thought of ​​shifting again in such a short time!

My husband is once again a good idea to move again to get monetary savings or stay in place and just mortgage the mortgage more aggressively than our revenue will increase. He’s a very comfortable and adventurous one that may be virtually in all places and in virtually all circumstances. I have a robust – maybe impatient – want to be debt free (and mortgage) sooner quite than later

Want for extra variety

I want to add that I also needed to develop into more diversified because we are within the neighborhood an excessive minority (~ 1%), although it’s an hour from Atlanta Metro Station. As well as, the type of work I hope for sooner or later is various – socio-economic variety and otherwise – and issues of coverage and schooling reform. These are the primary causes I went to a regulation faculty. On this basis, it might be practical to reside with totally different groups of the population, or at the very least to convey them closer to whether or not I must be pursuing knowledgeable profession as a lawyer in the public curiosity. Realistically, I can lastly simply write about this stuff from a distance, if we keep in place and primarily do research / pc work at home, however I would really like to be instantly involved locally sooner or later.

Jon and I are open to reside virtually anyplace on the earth, realistically we in all probability keep in Atlanta as long as it’s, the place we are, the larger families reside, and we save.

Jon and Naomi's Jobs

Jon is residence to 100% of the time as CFO. I am at present at house mom of four lapsellemme, and I'm serving to to lead the ladies's Bible research twice every week (the youngest goes with me to interact with different small). Regulation As well as I’ve a Grasp of Political Science and Spanish minor, a half I’ve been learning overseas in Spain. I'd like to come again to the workforce within the fall of 2019, which is when the youngest starts a preschool, I haven't found out exactly the place I want to work, regardless that I have a number of concepts and options, and I anticipate to earn about $ 2,000 a month, mainly working part-time, principally at house and largely about timetables for children's faculties and subsequently our plan to proceed working from residence, commuting is – fortuitously – one that we don't need to think about shifting round.

With Joni's youngest youngster

Jon and I’ve acquired a really low $ 80,000 entry for many of our 14.5-year anniversary, and we obtained married with one other faculty yr, and we had our first youngster on the end of next yr. regulation faculty and I stayed residence with the infant, then we had another youngster two years later s, so I by no means practiced regulation, although I've been in regulation. Through the years I labored part-time preschool instructor and watched the opposite children at residence to assist financially. I do not at present earn revenue, and the youngest baby is residence with me.

Joined a couple of years in the engineering business, Jon worked full-time in youth activities for a few yr at $ 40 Okay wage. Then we returned to Georgia and started working in a financial IT business that was not associated to his diploma, so he began a $ 46Okay starting wage. I agree with this to explain the background to save much less accumulation, as had been years when we didn’t do nothing, or very little retirement savings, because we merely cannot afford it.

Frugal By Nature

huge food finances, we reside fairly a bit. We don’t have automotive taxes because we have purchased used automobiles in money through the years and we should not have an interest-bearing credit card debt. I buy garments from savings shops and dispatch outlets, I really like to take my palms, and a rare whip often comes from the Goal clearing rack. Virtually each piece of furnishings in our house has been bought for use. We take a small cruise if we go all over the place. When our incomes have been earlier smaller, we didn't eat at all. I don't want to change loads of these sparing methods as a result of I take pleasure in getting plenty of trade and recycling / reusing gadgets, so wage will increase wouldn't change these ways.

Jon and Naom's House Buying and Promoting

bought our present house in March 2018 at $ 410Okay, utilizing $ 150Okay of equity to promote our earlier house as a prepayment when we initially had a $ 260,000 mortgage (30 years, 4.625%). I feel we could break (or shut to) the sale if we needed to promote 2019 in the spring / summer time. The house is situated within the desired neighborhood and faculty space, and the purchase worth was under the value of a built-in capital. If we are going to sell in this brief time period, we will attempt to stroll away from what we have set up at residence ($ 150Okay).

Naomi and Joni's New Neighborhood

The home has four,200 + square meters of 5 bedrooms, four.5 loos and a finished basement with a kitchenette. Our earlier residence was 2700 sq. meters and it was closing when we bought it. It was situated in an older, smaller space with no amenities. We lived there for seven years; Nevertheless, most of our shut associates have moved from the world in recent times, so we don't have robust private ties to the world, apart from teenage pals.

We purchased a brand new residence because we favored the neighborhood and its amenities (swimming pool, tennis, and so on.) and that our youngsters have extra children to play. In addition, this home has a more snug working area for Joni. I also needed to depart an open opportunity for an in depth relative and their baby when you need it, even if it didn't occur in the long run. Regardless of the costly buy worth, it was truly on the backside of this area.

Present Demise

Now – as you move into this new house just eight months ago – we are considering returning to the unique plan, leaving this more affluent area and "saving our chips" in order that we should buy a smaller house in a cheaper area. To make this home tougher this time, we could anticipate a summer time sale of our current house and reside briefly with our grandparents in the course of the search. Then we can be wanting to purchase a home within the worth range of $ 150,000 to $ 300,000, either and not using a mortgage (which would be my debt-free dream!) Or a 15-year mortgage that we would pay quicker with larger month-to-month payments. We would really like to give attention to looking for grandparents

Grandparents, who can be closer, wouldn’t come to our childcare, however they could see our children extra typically if we reside nearer to them. They each lead to very lively work and different private commitments, and now, when the younger two are somewhat older, childcare help is just not as robust as when this concept was first attracted a couple of years in the past. Nonetheless, it might be nice to be nearer to them as a result of we all take pleasure in one another's company. Once once more, so as to remove or lower our mortgage, we can turn into debt-free earlier than our oldest sources of colleagues and assist us higher pay for their training as needed. In any case, I want a smaller house to make it simpler to clear / keep, but we have an enormous household, so I'm making an attempt to be real looking with just that small we can go. We have appeared at the contractions in our current business, however smaller, cheaper houses are uncommon here.

Professional and Con Out of Shifting vs. Shifting

Advantages of non-movement:

  • Our college is considered wonderful
  • The world could be very prosperous, which signifies that every part is new or well-managed, well-managed, convenient and handy. there are many opportunities. Truthfully, social capital is bigger, and associates and acquaintances can supply jobs and different assets more easily; For example, I’ve provided tutorointityö- or educating work for my children, once I purchase in the grocery store, even when only pumppaisin fuel.
  • It is straightforward to continue with current routines and faculties
  • Jon is now an workplace in a finished basement with warmth and a door that he can shut for privateness. In our previous home he labored in an unfinished, unheated basement. We might not have as much area or as many creatures in our subsequent house, but we assume we could determine it out.
  • Children do not want to change faculty districts.

Disadvantages don’t move:

  • The world could be very prosperous, which suggests we assume that everyone can afford every thing or needs to buy every thing. For instance, faculty journeys are rather more expensive than the typical area trip (think about Disney World). Our children typically ask for additional things that their peers are like typical expenses, like going to a spring break for South Africa.
  • Variety is extremely limited, each socio-economic and others.
  • Dwelling prices might push me to work greater than we originally planned and work varieties that I won’t want to read (read: less versatile and much less household pleasant). Ideally, we would really like to stay out there through the working day for the different things of all four children (sick days, regular medical and dental visits, faculty membership actions, faculty holidays, subject journeys, homework, meal preparation, grocery stores, and so forth … as each mum or dad knows, the record goes on and on.


  • Faculties are highly respected in the area we are going to move, so there
  • There are smaller, cheaper houses which are simply accessible
  • We reside closer to grandparents
  • is a socio-economic variety and race / ethnicity variety that we value for a lot of reasons, certainly one of which is the kind of work I can do in the future (with under-utilized communities), and this may give our children a more practical picture of the world round them and a more representative view of themselves

Disadvantages of mobility:

  • Shifting and promoting again as soon as four children (although no less than some things are still in the shifting bins, ha!).
  • There’s more visitors within the space, however we both work at home for probably the most part, so it's not an enormous deal.
  • The oldest baby is somewhat hooked up to our current location (his faculty, his new room, his neighborhood, his associates) and can be unhappy / annoying to depart.
  • Children had to change faculty districts.

Where Naomi and Jon Want to Be Ten Years:

  • Lord:
    • Jon would really like to be prime management with his present company.
    • I would really like to do something that basically impacts someone's life. Serving in a disadvantaged faculty or helping an identical nonprofit organization. I actually hate that your postcode can decide quite a bit in your life, what faculties you are going to do, the quality of your schooling, your university outlook and your job prospects, I would really like to do one thing that impacts it, massive or small. I haven't given a whole lot of careers these days. I've been so targeted on the query "Move or stay," however I do perceive that all of it goes collectively. As a result of we nonetheless have small children who spend a number of time and have never practiced regulation (aside from a short internship at a faculty of regulation), I'm unsure that a lawyer is a career improvement I would really like to pursue in the close to future if ever, but who is aware of. I was just some years down the street, not ten, in my career. Since I would really like to work on a faculty yr schedule, spend breaks and summers with children, my greatest job alternatives (I feel) are:
      • freelance writing / running a blog
      • virtual schooling (on-line faculties or VIPKID)
      • teleworking sort job (least favorite however versatile)
      • job at college, perhaps educating US historical past, authorities, spanish (these would require some additional testing and however I taught Spanish in a personal preschool for three years when the women have been younger), or as a paraprofessional / sub-teacher
      • as a household success or youngster representative (though unsure if summers can be off
  • Finance:
    • debt-free!
    • 15% retire.
    • Generous Housing.
    • Pointless school or future funds for children.
  • Way of life:
    • Although we are usually not all in favour of raising our common expenses, we would really like to add some trips to our lives, now that nobody is in the diapers, much less want for sinks, and before the older two children go to school
    • We also want to assist pay for all four of our school to give more generous for many who want, and perhaps improve the cost of small hobbies.
    • Jon plays basketball on weekends however would really like to be a part of the league and participate in triathlons and different races.
    • We additionally spend a number of time at residence and would really like to work together extra with our group in a means that respects God.
    • I don't thoughts having a fitness class in the health club, growing an excellent sized backyard and cooking extra detailed meals the place you’ll be able to share with family, associates and even visitors. I additionally considered writing a e-book. All of those "extra" activities (for my part) require leisure items, which would mean both work or very flexible part-time work.

Naomi and Joni's Financial system

Monthly Revenue

Item Quantity Notes Gross Revenue (Jon) $ 9,500 $ 114,000 salary divided by 12 months. Jon additionally gets a 12% annual bonus, however we don't take that as a result of we don't want to rely upon it. Statutory Reductions – $ 1,198 Federal and State Taxes, Social Security, Medicare ] Well being, Dental and Visible Insurance coverage – $ 285 401Okay Payments – $ 570 Healthcare Savings Account (HSA) – $ 642 We will give the very best amount to HSA now to pay for future invoice for ER visit earlier this yr, and for our older two children. Month-to-month internet funds are paid after the above deductions: $ 6,805 Annual Internet Revenue: $ 81,660

Monthly Expenses

Item Quantity Notes
Mortgage ] $ 1,776 Consists of property taxes and home-owner insurance. 30 years, confirmed to 4.625 %, would really like to change to 15 years (if we stay here) once I start working or earnings.
Food and Household Supplies $ 1,060 Our family, 6 years previous. Consists of lunch for 2 children and home items.
Tithe $ 916 Not negotiable. We will (give) as part of our religion.
Clothing / Buying / Faculty Charges / misc. $ 300
Automated Upkeep / Repair $ 248 We do not use this quantity each month, however this is what we finances / save in this class.
Eating Out $ 219
Naomi Scholar Loans $ 216 1.625% Interest Fee. This payment will regularly improve each two years. The full quantity of the loan was $ 58Okay.
House Upkeep / Repair $ 213 We don’t use this amount every month, but this is the price range / savings on this category.
Presents $ 186 Birthdays and Christmas
Petrol / Gasoline $ 150
Preschool $ 136
Refrigerator Cost Plan $ 128 zero% zero% curiosity date is April 2019 (the house we purchased was not a fridge)
Utilities: Electrical energy $ 107
Missionary help $ 100 We give month-to-month pals to the overseas mission and we continue
Automotive Insurance $ 92
Utilities: Fuel $ 87
HOA $ 78
Holiday $ 73
Utilities: Water $ 70
Cellular Telephones (By way of Verizon) $ 66 Three iPhones. The precise invoice is $ 146, however Joni's job costs $ 80. The teenager "pays" for his share of this bill by nursing his youthful siblings three hours a month.
Jon's Scholar Loan $ 61 1.75% Curiosity Fee. Will probably be paid off in March 2019. The entire quantity of this loan was $ 31Okay
Joni's private cash $ 50
Naomi's personal money $ 50
Life Insurance $ 43 [1965999]] Lawn Care [19659098] $ 32
Pest Control $ 28
Internet (by way of Comcast) $ 25 The precise bill is $ 70, but $ 45 is changed by Joni's job.
$ 16
Automotive Identifier and Registration $ 14
Netflix $ eight
Xbox $ 5
Month-to-month Complete Value: $ 6,553
19659108] Complete annual bills: [19659099] $ 78,636
Distinction between monthly revenue and month-to-month bills: $ 252


Item Amount Notes Residence 180,000 $ prepayment $ 150,000 Conventional IRA $ 60,700 Emergency Fund $ 27,500 Preserved on a financial savings account of two.01% est 401Okay 22 $ 300 Complete: $ 290,500

Money owed

Merchandise Quantity Notes Mortgage $ 257,000 30 yr fastened mortgage price of four.625%. I would really like to change this for 15 years (if we do not move) once I begin working or if Joni's revenue will increase. This consists of property taxes and home-owner insurance coverage. Scholar loans from Naomi $ 44,900 1.625% interest rate. I am presently paying $ 216 a month and this cost is steadily growing each two years. The full quantity of the mortgage was $ 58,000. John's scholar mortgage $ 181 1.75% interest rate. He is presently paying $ 61 a month. It is going to be repaid in March 2019. The entire quantity of this loan was $ 31,000. Refrigerator Cost Plan $ 513 0% rate of interest; we still have four payments for $ 128; payday is April 2019 (the house we purchased was not a fridge) Complete: $ 302,594


Car Values ​​ Notes 2004 Honda Odyssey Minivan 2004] $ three,000 We have our automotive instantly. We have just one car, but as a result of we are each at house, it really works properly for us.

Questions from Naomi to you:

  1. Ought to we move and attempt for quicker debt freedom and a more numerous neighborhood? 19659005] Ought to we keep in place and enjoy the many issues we have to supply and pay our mortgage at regular velocity? Variety ought to simply be sought extra intentionally and less incessantly.
  2. Joni's place within the company he’s working in for the final yr, and with the new place he has an annual bonus. It isn’t assured, so we do not calculate it in our finances, however he received it this yr and is probably going to receive it. This yr's bonus was $ 11,702 (after taxes), and this quantity could not cowl the whole yr when he started his new job. What would we take into consideration our finances? Pay a mortgage, pay scholar loans, improve your retirement, start school funds or all the above mixtures?

. Frugalwoods Suggestions

We must start right now with a huge applause for Naomi and Joni. They crush it! They have four children (I'm honored, because I can barely handle two …), they are financially in fine condition, reside in the city where they want to reside, and they are engaged in life that they love! Method to go, you two !!!!! I have so much that I want to emphasize what they have completed simply earlier than discussing Naomi's questions, so I hope he’ll answer me when he outlines how nice he’s.

A +++++ On The Automotive

My candy 1996 Honda Odyssey minivuokraamo (which I not personal) [19659030] I’m so impressed with their fabulous determination to have just one automotive household of six family with out public transport (and not solely say this, because I additionally used to Honda ownership and love the Odyssey Mini Van). Hold on, I’ll say it once extra, just a little louder this time:

Naomi and Jon personal the ONE CAR in the SIX family neighborhoods without public transport.

It's a powerful presentation! !! And it saves them money. Critically, your complete boat's money simply helps its savings account. Right here's one more reason why this is so good: it's an older automotive that has purchased in cash. Was it all about this? They don't have a automotive charge. And it isn’t as a result of they’re millionaires because they made a wise determination to buy one thing they could afford to pay in cash and they haven’t any plans to upgrade it.

I am prepared to spend money on the tree (which I like the best way that their 2004 Honda Odyssey is among the oldest / least flagrant automobiles expensive neighborhoods isn’t straightforward to be in this place, however Naomi and Jon seem impervious to insidious want to comply with the Joneses They maintain.. – Joneses? Ketä kiinnostaa!!! Olisi mieluummin taloudellisesti vakaa ja meillä on paljon aikaa viettää lasten kanssa, kiitos paljon. Saatat ajatella, että puhun täällä paljon autosta, mutta tämä on tärkeää, ihmiset. Niin, että monta FOLKS-ohjelmaa haetaan yhden tai kahden auton maksuilla, jotka poistavat budjetin joka kuukausi. Uuden auton ostaminen on hirvittävää ajatusta ja auton hankkiminen, jota ei ole varaa, on samanlainen kauhea ajatus (varoitus siitä, että joskus henkilöllä on oltava auto, jotta hän pääsee töihin eikä sillä ole likviditeettiä ostaa Käteinen raha ). Mutta jos teillä on likviditeetti – tai mahdollisuus odo ttaa ja säästää – laitat itsesi mieleen taloudellisesti.

Tässä on lisätietoja siitä, miksi käytettyjen autojen ostaminen (ja pitäminen) on niin loistava concept:

Siirrä Tai ei liikuta

Naomin ja Jonin vanhan talon takana oleva rakennus

Tämä on todellakin kysymys. Tämä on yksi niistä kysymyksistä, joilla ei ole selkeää oikeaa vastausta, joten en voi antaa Naomille ja Jonille lopullista vastausta. Mutta mitä sanon, on se, että jos he harkitsevat tätä niin pian sen jälkeen, kun he ovat siirtyneet upeaan kotiin toivotulla alueella, he luultavasti haluavat liikkua. Ja jos näin on, jos he haluavat kovasti liikkua, heidän pitäisi tehdä se. He ovat riittävän hyvässä taloudellisessa kunnossa heiluttamaan sitä, ja vaikka se ei ole välitön taloudellinen voitto, se saattaa heijastua heille pitkällä aikavälillä.

Naomi on tehnyt herculean -työnsä, jossa se kuvaili kaikkia mahdollisia pro tämän askeleen, joka osoittaa, että tämä on hänen mielessään jatkuvasti. Naomille ja Jonille ei ole mitään syytä elää jossakin paikassa, jossa he eivät rakasta, eivätkä he tarvitse tehdä niin työpaikoilla, työmatkoilla tai taloudellisista syistä. Naomi ja Jon ovat tehneet vuosien varrella varovaisia ​​taloudellisia valintoja, mikä tarkoittaa, että heillä on joustavuus ottaa hieman kylpyamme tässä myynnissä.

Naomi ei minun näkökulmastani pyytänyt meitä siitä, jos hän ei olisi todella haluavat tehdä sen. Jos hän oli tyytyväinen uuteen kotiinsa ja tuntui asettua siellä, ajatus liikkua uudelleen ei edes edes poiketa hänen mielessään. Mutta ajatus on kylvetty ja hän työllistää sitä. Tämä mielestäni harkitseva taso osoittaa, että hän haluaa liikkua. Kyllä, se on massiivinen hässäkkä, kyllä ​​se juoksee lapset, ja kyllä ​​he saattavat menettää rahaa. Mutta jos se saa ne kotiin ja naapurustoon, he todella rakastavat?

Totisesti, todella pienenee

Jos he päättävät tehdä tämän liikkeen, heidän täytyy sitoutua massiiviseen supistukseen. To ensure that the funds to work out in the long run, they’d need to target houses which might be dramatically inexpensive than their present property. From a monetary perspective, it wouldn’t be value it to downsize to a house that’s say, $50Okay inexpensive. But when they went for a home that’s $200Okay inexpensive? They could be dwelling Naomi’s debt-free dream sooner quite than later!

I get the sense that Jon and Naomi are lots like me and my husband: the two of us could reside in a really small area and be perfectly content material. Nevertheless. It’s not simply the two of us or the 2 of them. Children have a means of remodeling the way you view, make the most of, and prioritize area. In mild of that, I encourage Jon and Naomi to define how they’d match their brood right into a smaller house. Could the youngsters share rooms? Could Jon’s workplace be in the main bedroom? What other issues do they want to consider? Is having a guest room a priority? What a few play/rec room? The truth of children is that they require area and working from house additionally requires area. Since Mr. FW and I each do business from home (one thing that Naomi and Jon are considering), we want two devoted workplaces. Mr. FW’s is up in our main bedroom and mine is downstairs in a room behind our woodstove (this room doubles as a visitor room too). Point being: there are ways to make it work in many various measurement houses, however Jon and Naomi are presently located in a home that meets all of their bedroom and office area wants.

Home Hunt In Advance

I feel Jon and Naomi’s pain on making an attempt to house hunt with two little youngsters in tow, and so, I recommend they begin perusing houses now. Go every time they will–even when it’s just one or the opposite of them–and get a real read available on the market of their desired neighborhood. How previous are these houses? Would loads of maintenance be required? How little can they spend and still get sufficient area for his or her household? If Jon and Naomi can go to some potential houses in their desired worth vary, I feel that might go a great distance in helping them make this determination. Taking a look at properties on-line is an effective start line, however seeing them in individual permits you to visualize your self dwelling in an area. Be trustworthy about where the youngsters and the workplaces will go.

Make A Move Before Excessive Faculty Starts

As a child whose mother and father bent over backwards not to move while I used to be in high school, I want to strongly advocate that Jon and Naomi do the identical. Typically, shifting throughout high school is unavoidable, but Jon and Naomi can avoid it and so I recommend they do. Naomi talked about that their thirteen-year-old can be irritated to move, and I think about those sentiments will only improve as she gets older. Ideally, the household would move through the summer time so that the youngsters aren’t changing faculties mid-year.

Determine Houses Earlier than Selling

It feels like Naomi and Jon bought their previous residence prior to buying their new house and then felt in a scramble to purchase one thing. I don’t advise they purchase a new house before promoting their current residence, but I do recommend that they get a very good concept of the varieties of houses they could buy. They don’t want to find themselves in this position once more. Naomi has already recognized that they could stay with her in-laws after promoting their present house and before purchasing a brand new house, which feels like an amazing concept. Buying a home whereas rushed shouldn’t be a sensible plan and not often leads to getting precisely what you want and can afford. If Naomi’s in-laws are advantageous to host them for an unspecified amount of time, that appears preferrred since they reside within the new faculty district the youngsters can be attending. Naomi has already outlined this timeline and it is sensible:

  • Sell their present house in late spring/summer time 2019 (they’d want to make sure that the youngsters could finish out the varsity yr of their current district)
  • Move in with Jon’s mother and father
  • Start the youngsters in their new faculty in fall 2019
  • Naomi starts part-time work in fall 2019
  • Home hunt
  • Purchase a brand new residence in fall 2019/winter 2020

A number of other issues:

  • Would they need to put their belongings in storage whereas staying with Jon’s mother and father? How a lot would that value per 30 days?
  • Would they pay Jon’s mother and father lease/utilities/food? I recommend they’ve a frank dialog ahead of time and iron out how this may be dealt with as well as to the place everyone would sleep and work.
  • Would Jon’s firm reimburse him for a co-working area during this time interval (if there’s not a great spot for him to work at his mother and father’ house)?
  • Is it feasible for the household to move, buy a new house, and have Naomi begin a new job all in the identical time period? I’m not saying it’s not, I’m simply saying that it’s quite a bit.

The Financial Angle

The pool in Naomi and Jon’s new neighborhood

I can’t say that it’s a wonderful financial choice to sell a home so shortly after shopping for it. Nevertheless, there’s additionally the sunk costs fallacy and the concept if this isn’t where Naomi and Jon want to be, they shouldn’t stay. I’m unsure they’ll give you the option to break even on selling their house, but I don’t know something concerning the Atlanta area housing market. With Realtor and transaction charges, it’s often robust to break even when promoting a home in such a short while body.

That being stated, if they commit to shopping for a vastly cheaper house (within the range of $150Okay), they could do exactly wonderful even if they lose some cash in this sale. Run the numbers, have a Realtor come over to appraise the house, and do some critical home searching in the desired new neighborhood to gauge what’s practical from both a measurement and a worth perspective.

Naomi and Jon’s Expenses

These two are already in the frugal category, so I don’t assume we’ll discover numerous room to lower their expenses. As Naomi has already recognized, their real problem is how much they spend on their mortgage every month, which could be but one more reason to go ahead and downsize. However it wouldn’t be a Frugalwoods Case Research with out an expense perusal, so let’s take a peek.

In each single Case Research, I like to level out that what you choose to save or not save is a very private choice. Slicing every last expense is NOT the correct reply for everyone and I’m NOT an advocate for making yourself miserable within the strategy of attaining monetary stability. I AM an advocate for values-based, goal-oriented spending. I feel it’s essential to assess whether your whole bills deliver you achievement and a great return on your funding.

I feel it’s additionally essential to query in case your fee of financial savings will aid you to obtain your long-term objectives. But what you spend on? That’s a very private selection and one you might have to make for your self. My job is to point out areas the place you may have the opportunity to save, but only you possibly can determine if that degree of savings is best for you. For those who’re struggling with where to save extra and how to map out a longterm financial plan, I encourage you to take my free 31-day Uber Frugal Month Challenge.

Ok, with that stated, let’s check out potential financial savings for Naomi and Jon:

  • Groceries and Household Supplies: $1,060. This sounds actually high, however then once more, that is to feed six individuals and manage the household needs for six individuals, so from that perspective, it truly sounds fairly affordable. Without understanding precisely what they buy in this class, it’s robust to say whether or not they could save. But, this could be a spot to scale back spending. In the event that they really feel there could be a chance to scale back spending on this class, I recommend the following posts for ideas:
  • Clothing/Buying/Faculty exercise fees/misc: $300. I all the time encourage individuals to do a little bit of digging on any class that incorporates “miscellaneous.” It’s extremely potential these are all obligatory bills, but, if Jon and Naomi are hoping to scale back their spending, identifying a number of the misc here is perhaps useful.
  • Dining Out: $219. Not a deal-breaker for Jon and Naomi, but it is an space they could scale back or remove, depending on how shortly they want to attain debt freedom.
  • Presents: $186. This doesn’t sound high until you understand that it’s $2,232 per yr on birthday and Christmas presents. That being stated, Naomi and Jon have four children. However, this seems fairly steep to me. I recommend looking at this category and figuring out if presents want to be restructured. For example, maybe used presents for the youthful youngsters (that’s what I do) and exercise or sport-specific presents for older youngsters? Or maybe entire family presents comparable to a museum membership or a pool table? These are simply random ideas I’m spouting, however the point it, there is perhaps an actual alternative to each spend much less and train their youngsters about decreasing consumerism and material wants.
  • Vacation: $73. This isn’t an enormous dollar quantity, so I’m not likely concerned, however I am pointing it out as a discretionary expense.
  • Particular person cash for Jon and Naomi: $50 each ($100 complete). Not a ton of money, however again, another discretionary expense that could be eradicated relying on how desperate they’re for debt freedom.

Jon bike driving with one in every of their children

Naomi and Jon aren’t in a determined financial state of affairs, in order that they’re lucky that they don’t have to make these cuts to their spending. Nevertheless, Naomi reiterated a number of occasions that she actually needs to be debt-free. Provided that, if they determined to scale back their grocery bill by $75, scale back the clothing/purchasing/faculty exercise charges/misc by $50, get rid of the $219 in eating out, scale back presents by $100, get rid of trip and personal cash, they’d have the ability to save $617 extra per thirty days (which is $7,404 per yr). 

Once more, I’m not saying that they have to or want to remove these expenses, however these are the discretionary classes as I see them.

Moreover… Naomi and Jon are about to get a boost to their month-to-month financial savings in the type of the ultimate payments on Jon’s scholar loan and their fridge! Those last funds are arising in spring 2019 and, after they’re paid off, Naomi and Jon will save an extra $189 per 30 days (also referred to as $2,268 per yr)!

Furthermore… IF Jon and Naomi determine to move and IF they’re in a position to downsize and find a cheaper residence, it’s extremely probably they’ll have the ability to scale back their mortgage, spend much less on utilities, and get rid of HOA charges, lawn care, and maybe pest care too.

Okay so in the event that they decided to save the outlined $617 per 30 days and then we add within the $189 they’ll start saving as soon as Jon’s scholar loan and the refrigerator are paid off, they’d be on monitor to save a further $806 per 30 days, which is also called $9,672 per yr.

This extra savings, coupled with a inexpensive residence (and cheaper utilities, no HOA, and so forth) would quick monitor Naomi and Jon to debt freedom in a really brief period of time. Then, they could start build up their retirement and school financial savings for his or her youngsters. Talking of which, let’s talk about their…

Asset Allocation

A flowery approach of saying “how you use your money.” I’m thrilled to see Naomi and Jon’s wholesome emergency fund! At $27,500, their emergency fund would cover just over four months value of expenses for them, which is perfect. An emergency fund must be stored in an easily-accessible bank account, comparable to a checking or financial savings account (like Naomi and Jon have carried out), NOT in investments, retirement funds, or automobiles/houses/expensive china. An emergency fund is cash cash you’ll be able to entry immediately in an emergency. I recommend saving three to six months’ value of expenses, which means three to six months value of what you spend each month, which is why it’s crucial to monitor your bills and know what you spend every month. Should you’re not tracking your spending, you possibly can sign-up for the free service Personal Capital, which is what I exploit and advocate for expense tracking (affiliate link).

Next up, I’m glad to see that Jon is contributing to his 401Okay and that the couple has an IRA. As Naomi noted, nevertheless, they could stand to beef up their retirement savings given their ages and the greenback amounts they at present have saved. To provide Naomi and Jon a common sense on how much they should have saved for retirement at this stage, Constancy has a helpful rule of thumb:

Goal to save at the least 1x your salary by 30, 3x by 40, 6x by 50, 8x by 60, and 10x by 67.

Given this, Naomi and Jon ought to have saved 3 times Jon’s gross wage (he’s 39). That’d be 3 x 114,000 = $342,000. While this might sound insurmountable right now, I’m not fearful about Naomi and Jon. As Naomi outlined, Jon’s wage solely just lately elevated to six figures and they are clearly adept at frugalizing and making it work. Plus, Naomi has her eye on decreasing their month-to-month outlay whereas growing their revenue. All that to say, while they do have some catching up to do–and I might advocate prioritizing their retirement financial savings–I’m additionally confident they’ll get there.

Now let’s deal with their debt. Naomi and Jon are carrying debt with very low (or no) interest rates, which is what we like to see if we see debt in any respect. I like to recommend they pay off Jon’s scholar mortgage and the refrigerator as scheduled this spring (no purpose to speed up these payments given the low rates of interest). Next up is Naomi’s scholar mortgage of $44,900. Usually, I’d push for her to pay this off ASAP; nevertheless, the rate of interest on this can be a paltry 1.625%, which suggests I’m much less concerned. I share Naomi’s aversion to debt, but she’s clever to see this rate of interest for what it’s: very low. Given how low it’s, and how little they’ve in retirement and school savings, I’m going to advocate Naomi just continue to pay this off as scheduled–as long as that interest rate is fastened and gained’t balloon sooner or later. If Jon and Naomi scale back their value of dwelling and make different cuts to their spending–and if Naomi goes back to work–they could have enough cash to wipe this debt out utterly, which would be fantastic. However given their present asset allocations, I wouldn’t advocate accelerating cost here.

What To Do With Jon’s Bonus?

I LOVE this question because I LOVE that Jon and Naomi want to be considerate about this additional cash. They’re not going to blow it on a brand new automotive or clothes, they’re going to correctly allocate their assets. So, from that perspective, as long as they make a rational determination, there isn’t a mistaken answer. With money, the fallacious reply is often the un-considered, un-thoughtful, un-math based mostly reply. And Jon and Naomi don’t roll that method.

At this level, I feel that any extra cash must be prioritized in the direction of maxing out their retirement savings, as I mentioned above.

As I mentioned, I wouldn’t essentially prioritize paying off Naomi’s scholar loan. And I personally wouldn’t prioritize paying off their present mortgage at an accelerated price. This debate is as previous because the hills and individuals fall into one camp or one other, but for what it’s value, listed here are my thoughts:

  • A paid-off house is an excellent thing, however you’ll be able to’t use a paid-off home to buy groceries or pay for medical insurance for those who’ve misplaced your a job (you may have the opportunity to get a House Fairness Line Of Credit, however that’s not a assure and definitely not when you’ve misplaced your jobs). A paid-off home is an illiquid asset (until you’re in a position to promote it shortly, which is an unknown).
  • There are alternative costs to paying off a mortgage. Specifically, you’re lacking out on the potential investment returns you’d take pleasure in in case your money was as an alternative invested in the stock market. Mr. FW and I select to hold mortgages on each our main residence and our rental property as a result of, mathematically, our money is best deployed in the stock market thanks to the typical annual price of return (7%) you could anticipate after many many years of remaining invested in low-fee index funds. Primarily, money is best leveraged in the inventory market than in a paid-off house.
  • In case you have a low fastened rate of interest mortgage, then from a mathematical standpoint, I wouldn’t pay it off early. I view holding a mortgage–and having money correctly invested in diversified belongings (aka low-fee index funds)–to be a a lot less dangerous determination.
  • A mortgage is a wonderful hedge towards inflation. Inflation is when cash turns into much less helpful and the neat thing a few mortgage is that it’s denominated within the dollars you initially paid for the home and so, over time, as inflation will increase (which usually occurs), the money you’re using to pay off your mortgage is “cheaper.” Primarily, it’s not dangerous to hold a mortgage and it’s truly a wonderful element of a diversified portfolio of belongings. Paying off your mortgage to the detriment of investing is rather a lot like placing your whole eggs in a single basket.
  • It’s not that it’s a nasty factor to repay a home–it’s just that it comes at the expense of other opportunities to grow wealth. Many of us who are early retired/financially unbiased choose to maintain mortgages–although we could afford to pay them off tomorrow–for the above reasons. Bottom line: financial independence can occur with a mortgage; however it absolutely can’t occur without cash available.

Nevertheless, if they have been to get into a home with no mortgage, or a very small mortgage, and debt-freedom is their dream, they could easily funnel additional savings and Jon’s bonuses into paying off their mortgage.

Naomi additionally requested about saving for school for his or her youngsters and I’ll inform them what I tell everyone: you possibly can take out loans to pay for school, but you can’t take out loans to fund your retirement. It’s very a lot a “put your own oxygen mask on first” sort of state of affairs. Mother and father want to guarantee their very own retirement is strong earlier than beginning to save for their youngsters’ larger schooling. Nevertheless, because it seems very probably Naomi and Jon may have extra discretionary money in the future, establishing 529s or different savings automobiles for his or her youngsters could be clever. 529s could be a good suggestion as contributions are typically tax advantaged (you don’t get a federal tax deduction, only a state tax deduction in some states), however that is actually dependent upon your revenue tax price and the laws governing your state. Naomi and Jon ought to definitely do extra research into 529s and determine if that is perhaps right for them.

A Word On Gross vs. Internet Revenue

Naomi and Jon get a gold star on this one. You understand how I’m all the time harping on the distinction between your gross revenue and your internet revenue? That’s as a result of there’s a HUGE difference between these two numbers. Naomi did an superior job outlining Jon’s salary and so I’m going to paste it here again for reference:

Item Amount Notes Gross Revenue (Jon) $9,500 $114Okay salary, divided by 12 months. Jon additionally receives a 12% annual bonus, however we don’t embrace that right here because we favor not to depend upon it. Statutory deductions -$1,198 Federal and state taxes, Social Security, Medicare Well being, dental, and vision insurance -$285 401Okay contributions -$570 Well being Financial savings Account (HSA) -$642 We contribute the utmost quantity to our HSA proper now in order to pay for an upcoming bill for an ER go to earlier this yr as well as braces for our older two youngsters. This contribution will doubtless be reduce in half beginning in January 2019. Month-to-month internet “take home” revenue after the above deductions: $6,805

It’s straightforward to overlook deductions and simply assume that your gross and internet (aka your “take home”) pay are the identical, but they never are. As you possibly can see from the above, with a regular set of deductions, Jon’s take house pay is absolutely $2,695 much less per thirty days than his listed salary. Naomi and Jon are all over this, which is why they find themselves in such a cushty place. Should you’re not sure of your gross vs. internet revenue, take an in depth take a look at your paycheck stub or speak with your HR division.

P.S. thank you for letting me use you as an exquisite example, Naomi!!


  1. Begin taking a look at homes of their desired neighborhood ASAP to get a sense of how small they could go and what worth vary they’d realistically be taking a look at.
  2. Have a Realtor appraise their present residence.
  3. Determine if they want to move.
  4. In the event that they DO want to move, determine if it’ll be this spring/summer time or subsequent spring/summer time. In mild of the varsity schedules of Jon and Naomi’s youngsters, in addition to the probably youngsters of prospective consumers, I think about summer time is the time to sell for prime greenback.
  5. Iron out the small print of dwelling with Jon’s mother and father prematurely: lease, utilities, food, bedrooms, workspaces, storage unit, and so forth.
  6. Record the home and hope it sells shortly!
  7. Prioritize beefing up their retirement accounts with any extra cash that comes their approach (by way of Jon’s bonus or a inexpensive mortgage).
  8. Decide if they want to scale back their expenses further in order to make quicker progress on paying down debt and/or build up retirement savings and/or investments and/or school accounts.
  9. Take pleasure in life! Naomi and Jon are doing wonderfully nicely and ought to respect and take pleasure in it.

Okay Frugalwoods nation, what recommendation would you give to Naomi? She and I will each reply to feedback, so please be happy to ask any clarifying questions!

Would you want your personal case research to seem right here on Frugalwoods? E-mail me ( your temporary story and we’ll speak.

Never Miss A Story

Enroll to get new Frugalwoods tales in your e mail inbox.